Thursday, April 1, 2010

Smaller Government?

The Tea Party Express rolled into Denver yesterday. I saw on the news the signs they bounced in their hands in a didactic gesture of insistence. “Small government” was one of the more prominent ones they shook with anger and self righteousness.
And then reality began to confront their plea in my memory bank. I began to think about the last time I stood in line for any length of time. No, it wasn’t to get tickets to the opera or the symphony or even a play at the Space Theatre. It was at the Post Office. I had gone there to retrieve my mail after being out of town for a few weeks. There was one person working behind the counter, there were two people in front of me, and there was a line forming and lengthening behind me as we waited for the woman who was insuring a package, buying stamps, and generally accomplishing all of her little missions that had brought her to the Post Office that morning.
I can remember a time when no matter how long the line was, I could get in and out of the Post Office in a few minutes because there were three people working the counter. Not today. Today, thanks to smaller government, I have to wait about a half hour to forty-five minutes to get my mail early in the morning on a Monday or Tuesday.
Then I began recalling the last time I had to go to the DMV for a car registration or a driver’s license renewal. I remember spending hours trying t get what I needed and lost almost a full day of work in the process. It seems the volume of business at the DMV is far greater than its capacity to handle it, so small government in this instance appeared to be costing productivity in the workplace a great deal.
When I was in New Zealand a couple of months ago, I noticed that road crews were everywhere patching and sealing the already magnificent roads and in the process completely eliminating any road hazards due to potholes or cracks. At this time of year in Denver, unless you have a large SUV with oversized tires, you are apt to put your front end out of alignment by dropping into some significant potholes everywhere around town. Of course, New Zealand has a more socialist government than we do, so they put social services such as national health care and road repair ahead of any shorter-sighted call for lower taxes and smaller government.
I don’t know about you, but I remember what happened when we relaxed some rules governing Wall Street during the last thirty years of the 20th Century after we seemed to forget what brought them into existence to begin with, thinking that a freer Wall Street and less government interference would be a good thing for everybody. And so we bought into trickle-down or supply-side thinking for a few decades. It turned out the government had to act about as big as you can get in the end in order to salvage the world economy from complete collapse. Had it stayed a bit bigger and more powerful to begin with, the collapse would have been prevented.
Today we have these multinational corporations that have budgets larger than most countries out there doing business in their own interest, as they are designed to do. Without big or powerful government, who is going to ensure that these corporations contribute to the greater good at the same time they make a profit for their stockholders, who tend to be rather insistent that their investments yield short term returns on a regular basis. Who is going to help guide these huge corporations on a long term course that raises the world’s quality of life as well as the already high standard of living enjoyed by investors even higher? Would you suggest The United Nations? I think not. The only government capable of doing that is the U.S. government, unless we shrink it and let the Chinese and its directed economy bury us. And unless it remains large and powerful, it will be run over by all sorts of powerful entities with a lot more resources than the Tea Party crowd.
You want “smaller government”? Corporations, China, India, even the European Union are licking their collective chops! What are you thinking, Tea Partiers! If you want to protest something, protest against fast food and industrialized agriculture, not big government. The former will shorten your lives; taxes never have. And drink some green tea instead of throwing it in the sea of your misdirected discontent.

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

The McCarthy Legacy

Back in the early 1950’s America was haunted by a witch-hunter named Joseph McCarthy. He was a mainly a one man show who managed to work up an anti-communist frenzy across the country which resulted in a lot of professional lives left in ruin and a national paranoia the likes of which has not been seen in America until the election of our first black President and the subsequent rise of the Tea Party movement. I remember the McCarthy hearings well, for they were the first day time television I had witnessed as a child growing up among what would be called moderate Republicans today.
Ever since the Obama election liberals have been the proverbial frogs in the kettle of water. In these times, there are numerous voices heating up the witch-hunt, fueling the fire that heats the water that eventually will boil the frogs unless they have the wisdom to simply stop sitting there pretending they can take the heat of the conservatives’ cauldron when in fact the temperature is near the boiling point. These heat-generating irrational voices come from Fox News, talk radio, the House of Representatives, the Senate: in short, they are a siren-like chorus that enchants and infuriates the public to such a degree that the bricks and spit have already begun to fly. Guns and grenades may be just around the corner. Enough of taking the heat.
Meanwhile, the national conversation has shifted to such a conservative extreme that what was once moderate Republican thinking is now labeled socialist or liberal. For example, the health care bill that the House just passed is a mere shadow of what Nixon proposed in the 1970’s. What used to be Republican thinking is now labeled socialist, and what is now Republican thinking is simply anti-governmental or the party of NO.
Most of the Tea Party types are losers. They think like losers and act like losers. That’s what happens when you think only defensively, only reductively, only negatively. You define your existence by what you are against, not for. You score no points because you are too busy trying to prevent the other side from scoring any. It is a strategy that goes nowhere but down.
The Democratic Party seized the middle of the political spectrum in the last election and has slowly but carefully maintained a centrist course, much to the chagrin of true liberals, who would much rather have seen an expanded Medicare program come out of congress than this 30 million new accounts cornucopia for the insurance industry.
However, the new McCarthy-ites are not having any of it, even if the bill is mostly derived from old Republican ideas. They want less government, or even no government, because they have nowhere to go philosophically except further right into some wild new frontier of libertarian nihilism, the middle ground having been occupied by the Democrats because the middle ground was vacated by the right as they looked for higher ground from which to look down on the land they relinquished. They sooner or later will find that the soil is rather thin the higher you go. So they are left with nothing but denial: No nothing. No. Just say no.
The problem in America is that the true liberal has been left behind, disenfranchised, by the Democratic Party shift to the middle. You would never know it as a problem because the extreme right holds most of the apparent microphones and megaphones. In fact, actual liberal views are buried beneath whatever ground is being managed by the party in power namely, the Democrats.
The good news is that as long as the Tea Party folks have sway over the Republicans, the Democrats can rest assured that the Republicans will be a long time in trying to reclaim that very fertile middle ground.

Monday, March 8, 2010

The Assumption Divide

The things that separate conservatives and liberals begin with very different assumptions about what is important and what works. All of their approaches to problem-solving stem from their often differing assumptions about responsibility, function, and progress. Here are a few of the assumptions conservatives (Con) and liberals (Lib) tend to embrace:
1. Con: Capitalism creates competition, and that is good.
Lib: Cooperation rather than competition serves the people best.
2. Con: The “playing field” will never be level and never has been.
Lib: The “playing field” can be made more level through law and policy.
3. Con: The individual is entirely responsible for his/her own outcome.
Lib: Government’s job is to protect the weak from the exploitation of the strong.
4. Con: Criminals should be punished. (stick)
Lib: Criminals should be rehabilitated. (therapy, education)
5. Con: Economies must grow to survive.
Lib: The ideal economy is sustainable.
6. Con: That which governs best governs least.
Lib: Government should be a player, not just a referee.
7. Con: People are self-interested, motivated by fear and greed, driven by competition.
Lib: People are naturally good, like to work, and tend to contribute to society.
8. Con: Caveat Emptor (Let the buyer beware.)
Lib: Caveat Venditor (Let the seller beware.)
9. Con: Market volatility is the price for opportunity.
Lib: Economic security is more important than getting rich.
10. Con: Wealth is a right.
Lib: Wealth is a privilege.
11. Con: Health care is a privilege.
Lib: Health care is a right.

There are many more assumptions that both liberals and conservatives make, but these are enough to show that most political positions assumed by either group are based on assumptions about human behavior.
Conservatives assume that human nature is untrustworthy, selfish, and by nature aggressive, so why not accept those “facts” and build an economic system that utilizes that nature? If folks get out of hand, simply punish them. Otherwise, let the system self-correct. Capitalism, for them, is as close to a perpetual motion economic machine as mankind can find.
Liberals, on the other hand, always seem to want to give mankind the benefit of the doubt and assume that people can be cooperative, can change, and can be reformed with just the right therapy or positive incentive. They also see losers as victims of the system rather than flawed individuals who simply don’t have the gumption to pull themselves up by their bootstraps (not that anyone wears bootstraps these days) and try again. The conservative likes to use old adages like the one referring to bootstraps to validate his view that losers remain losers because they give up trying to win.
Each group’s assumptions about human nature are, in part, the direct result of the other’s existence. They are a chicken and egg duo that continues to drive politics today. Neither is entirely right or wrong but is simply one side of the spectrum that is the reality of human nature.
There was a time when politics was a meeting place for ideas. Today, it is a battleground where self-righteous pontification takes the place of dialogue and the possible arrival at that “settlement in the wilderness” called Consensus. The U.S. Senate in particular is the primary locus of the most uncivil war since the one Lincoln presided over. Neither liberals nor conservatives have a handle on the exact nature of humankind, and therefore neither should be so trusting of the assumptions each holds so dear. Given the behavior they exhibit from either side of the aisle, they are in no position to make any claims on a true knowledge of human nature except that it is flawed and in need of something beyond the status quo.
Today’s health care debate is supposedly about principles. Most of it is about manufactured nonsense and irrational fear based on false assumptions. The debate does not even come down to the last pair of assumptions in the list: Is health care a right or a privilege? At whose profit is lack of health care justifiable and at whose is it not?
When the well-being of the corporation takes precedence over the well-being of the citizen, something has gone wrong with somebody’s assumption scheme, and something has to change. Otherwise, that old adage about “the strength of a society is measured by its capacity to care for its weak and elderly” has no currency, and we are left with the mechanistic ‘survival of the fittest. As a result, Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness as our ideals seem lost in the wake of survival mode.

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Obama: Lion or Lamb?

I normally don’t put much stock in Chinese New Year symbols, but this year, starting on February 14th, Valentine’s Day in the West, the Chinese will begin the year of the tiger. Now the only tiger we identify in our own culture is Tiger Woods, and since his stock is way down right now, the year of the tiger will probably remain ironic at best in the U.S. Our tiger is currently toothless and being retooled (I mean rehabbed) in Mississippi, where sex addiction is apparently best addressed, Mississippi and sex addiction treatment seeming strange bedfellows aside.
For the first year of his presidency, Barack Obama has been much the lamb. He has tried to reach out to Republicans, find common ground, pursue consensus, and leave the law-making to congress, all of which has led to a decline in the country’s perception of him as a leader. While the nation seems to like him as a person, when they can separate the two roles in their minds, they have concluded that he is not the leader they had hoped for. Had he lined up with the Chinese symbol of 2009, he would have adopted the persona of the ox, not a likely persona for the slim, fit, agile person that he is. Besides, the last think the country needed was a bull in a china shop approach to issues, although he might have used that image to good effect with Wall Street, who know a bull when they see one, or so they keep telling us.
What this country needs right now is a lion, not a lamb. It is time for Obama to take off the kid gloves, stand up to the Republicans, show them that they are mere capons, not roosters they think they are, and roar and claw his way back into the leadership role the country expected him to assume in the first place. He should stop being so accommodating to the Republicans, especially now that they have rearmed themselves with that insidious weapon of mass destruction: the filibuster. Now there is no reason for Obama to worry about appearing a bully.
The primary reason Scott Brown won so easily in the Massachusetts election for Ted Kennedy’s former seat was that Scott looks and acts like a leader. His opponent did not. The heavily and traditionally democratic Massachusetts electorate, representing the general electorate as a whole because it was the only election available, sent a signal to Washington that the American people are sensing a vacuum in leadership that actually both represents and leads them. It is tired of seeing what it perceives to be the continued tiptoeing, kowtowing, and slinking around among politicians who are funded and influenced by special interest groups like Wall Street, the insurance industry, Big Oil, or corporate health care. They are desperate for a representative of Main Street and they found their first potential hero in Scott Brown.
America is purportedly a nation whose majority is at least descended from the Christian tradition. It is ironic, therefore, to be asking the President to be more the lion than the lamb, given the historic relationship between the Christians and the lions. However, Americans have never been consistent or wholehearted in their application of Christian virtues and imagery. For example, America loves football, a very violent sport in which never a cheek is turned. America is not in a generous position or mood today, especially toward other Americans. It saves its generosity for disasters outside America, such as the aftermath of the earthquakes in Haiti.
Barack Obama is the head of the Democratic Party. No democratic candidate can look forward to the 2010 election unless Obama changes his persona and starts acting as if he is king of the jungle rather than a lamb being readied for a Republican spit. If he is not bolder, he may end up an isolated black sheep, an image the racists would surely love to promote. Lambs negotiate; lions don’t.
America would rather respect and gain confidence in a lion than lie down with a lamb.

Monday, January 11, 2010

Wanted: Untouchables

The old untouchables were the Federal good guy agents led by Eliot Ness in 1929 who waged a war against organized crime led by Al Capone of Chicago. The Eliot Ness folks were dubbed the untouchables because they were incorruptible. They were beyond bribery and undeterred by bullets.
Today, we have another menace that threatens the entire country, not just Chicago. It is the small group of the largest banks that brought our economy to its knees in the past two years and who continue to flaunt their own sense of imperviousness to accountability. They indulge in lavish bonuses for their top guns at the expense of the common taxpayer.
Like Capone, Wall Street has traded in toxic assets and operated above the law. In Capone’s time, he simply broke the law and traded in toxic assets called liquor, while ignoring Prohibition. Wall Street dealt in toxic assets that were bundled into derivatives which were traded outside the scope of the law. There were no regulations protecting the public from derivatives. Lloyd Blankfein, head of Goldman Sachs, was quoted as saying that his firm was “doing God’s work.” Al Capone, I am sure, was seen as a Godfather figure. However, Capone never asked the government for bail let alone a bailout.
Unlike Capone, Wall Street sees no government agency or government leader capable of challenging its self-indulgence because it has brethren carefully planted across the spectrum of government power that might, under less corrupt circumstances, exercise reform. Unfortunately there is nary a politician in Washington who has not benefitted from Wall Street’s campaign contributions, thanks to the lack of any real self-imposed campaign finance reform. Therefore, there is no eager Eliot Ness who might be commissioned by the federal government to regulate Wall Street. There appear to be no “untouchables” or even potential “untouchables” on the horizon. Or perhaps there are.
Another Eliot, Eliot Spitzer, once wielded a heavy sword on Wall Street as New York Attorney General, but unfortunately he had an Achilles heel attached to another appendage. Richard Blumenthal, the Connecticut A.G. who appears to have no hidden weaknesses, is now a candidate for the Senate replacing Chris Dodd who is “retiring.” Perhaps Blumenthal can step up and lead the reform effort, but we would have to wait until next year, and that will be too late to prevent the next cloudy bubble rising over Wall Street.
The current attorney general of the United States, Eric Holder, has yet to play his hand, if he legally has any cards to play. Perhaps he will find a way to bring Wall Street to justice and relieve America of the rage it feels toward Wall Street and government alike, both symbols of callous self-indulgence, capitalism at its worst, corruption, and complicity.
In any case, America needs a new generation of untouchables to come along and clean up the brazen disregard of what government and capitalism are meant to serve: namely, the people, not the Capones or the Wall Street Cojones.
The American people are not helpless in pursuing reform. They can become one gigantic group of untouchables themselves, and they can start by making three very effective moves:
1. Remove all investments and deposits connected with the large and culpable banks. Tear up credit cards connected with same.
2. Write current senators and representatives and tell them you want to see substantial and real reform of Wall Street before June, 2010.
3. From now on the people should elect only politicians who refuse corporate donations to their campaigns.
Tea Party folks take note: Given the size and power of the corporations, small government is the last thing you actually want first. What America needs first is actual representative government, which means “of the people, by the people, and for the people.” The only way that can happen is if we the people actually fund their campaigns instead of leaving it to the Wall Street or corporate machine.

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Wall Street Is Dodge City

You probably never thought Wall Street as a frontier town, but that is just what it is in the minds who occupy it. It is the last great place where you can make a fortune without fear of regulation and rules. You can mine for whatever you want and even make up products that never existed before you invented them. It is the last frontier where the sharp guys from the East finally outsmart the cowboys and end up owning the ranch. The Western has been replaced by the Eastern.
No sheriff need apply. As soon as there is any mention of a sheriff, the Wall Street gun-slingers try to stonewall the suggestion, insisting that they have things under control, or if they don’t, the Market (God) will provide the correction necessary to bring justice sooner or later. Trust in the Market, they say.
There is no other money moving institution left on earth that does not have some sort of regulation or accountability imposed on the players. That’s what makes Wall Street the last frontier, the Dodge City of the 21st Century.
For example, even in one of the most rough and tumble worlds in existence, the NFL, the players are not left to merely say “my bad” when they make a mistake such as hitting someone out of bounds or grabbing a face mask. They are penalized by referees who manage the game and impose regulations agreed upon by the owners to protect their investments, keep the game sustainable, and exercise justice.
In the recent Wall Street catastrophe, by contrast, there was not only no accountability for error, there was not even an apology forthcoming from any Wall Street banker, other than from Bernie Madoff after he had been caught with his hand in the biggest cookie jar ever. Deregulation clearly had led to chaos.
We as Americans love Westerns. We love the idea of being able to do whatever we want whenever we want to do it. However, we have generally agreed on rules and constraints in almost every sphere of life except on Wall Street. We may not like the specifics of some rules, but we are not disobeying those rules in large numbers. We tend to be law-abiding citizens. Besides, in most Westerns there is a sheriff who sooner or later exercises justice.
In the traditional Western, the good guys wore the white hats, the bad guys the black with slightly shorter brims, and the nerds wore Eastern clothes with a derby. Occasionally the derby was a bad guy, but most of the time he needed the defense of the white hats against the black. The white hats always won in the end, and the derby was either saved or marginalized.
How is it, then, that we have allowed the American Western narrative to be taken over by the Eastern where the nerdy investment banker “gets the girl”? It is an appalling metamorphosis and probably explains why the second amendment is so popular with the Western-minded “cowboys” who drive their pick-ups to their militia gatherings on weekends. They are trying to hang on to the last vestige of the narrative they were taught to believe but have been emasculated by the Easterner who has made Wall Street the “false” last frontier.
The increase in gun purchase of late has more to do with this transformation in the American narrative than any other single factor. Much has been said about it being the result of the election of a black President. That’s true for some but for most it is a deflection or scape-goat for the resentment of the more invisible or amorphous Wall Street nerd who, like the Wizard of Oz, is hidden from sight, unexposed, and therefore hard to scope as a visible target. Obama’s inaction to date keeps him firmly linked to the Eastern narrative in the minds of many.
Until the government makes clear that it will regulate this last and essentially un-Western frontier, the Western narrative will remain resurrected and just as dangerous in its own way as the Eastern narrative of wild Wall Street as Dodge City.

Friday, December 25, 2009

And the Capons Keep Scratching Around*

I have a new, more fitting symbol for the Republican Party. The elephant never was an appropriate mascot for the GOP because the beast is not native to America. You might argue that it is appropriate because the elephant belongs in a zoo or a circus and should not be allowed to run wild in America. I, in turn, would argue that now that the elephant is “in the room” or “on the table,” he is no longer something anyone wants to recognize or discuss. Although the elephant may never forget, what he remembers is some kind of good old days that never existed. His past is a foreign country, not America.
The donkey is a good fit for Democrats. He’s a steady worker, doesn’t lose its cool in adversity, and goes where no mere horse would dare. He helped settle the West. He may be stubborn, but he is able to tackle any terrain with confidence. He sometimes makes an ass of himself, but generally he is dependably dedicated to whatever work needs to be done.
The new symbol I would suggest for the GOP is the capon, a rooster without reproductive capacity. The capon gets fatter and tastier than a rooster, and projects an image of power and stature, but is essentially sterile and impotent. It’s a sort of Baby Huey: large and soft, mostly in the head.
Like the elephant, the capon in sufficient numbers can serve as a roadblock. These are chickens that do not cross the road to get to the other side but make certain nobody gets down the road to progress no matter what. They just sit in the middle of the road to somewhere better and squawk about how the Democrats are on the road to damnation when, in fact, the road is clearly one to real progress.
These capons are a cross between Chicken Little and Foghorn Leghorn: they cackle about socialism or whatever ism other than capitalism lurks in their nightmares, but are too paralyzed by the dead weight of their own convictions to move. They stay their course to nowhere, never offering any direction that does not loop back to where it started or put resources where they are least needed.
The capon is also fitting because it is almost entirely white meat. As an example, just look at Mitch McConnell. Doesn’t he look like a capon? And doesn’t Mitch kind of talk like one would talk if it could? Yes, I know, Rush Limbaugh looks much more like a capon than does Mitch McConnell. Still, can’t you envision the whole Republican caucus with their hands in their pockets scratching around some barnyard looking for a grain of truth among the scattered kernels of their philosophy? Mostly their philosophy is only so much cracked corn.
Let’s go with the capon. It is a new face on an old image, but a more appropriate one for these modern times.
* not to be confused with: "And the Caissons Keep Marching Along"